Like all of the products in the Pfister Rhen line, both the finish and design of this toilet paper holder are first class. When I purchased my products, there were few reviews on the Rhen line, but that is slowly changing. A matte black finish can look really horrible if it is not done just right, and Pfister got it right. I may also purchased the small, single towel round towel holder...still on the fence about it.Fell off the wall completely 3 times before my husband had to use his own screws to keep it in place. Color on photo is true to color in person. Very Very very yellow gold with no brass or rose hues. Terrible to get any water stains off of it. If a splash of water dries on this item it is hard to clean it off completely. In my opinion a very high maintenance and over priced item.